Sig p229 extractor problems Sig replaced the extractor and slide and I took it back to the range and put 200 rounds through it with no problems. ruling out steel-cased ammunition, The Firing Line Forums > Hogan's Alley > Handguns: The Semi-automatic Forum: Sig P229 SAS problems There is what could be called a "universal" locking insert that will work with P229-1 9mm, . Nah, the only problem the original/older P229's had were extraction/ejection problems (very few had a problem but it did exist. Quite a few years ago, a former Marine member had an issue with his Sig 1911 TACOPS . Before you ask, yes I clean and lubed it up as soon as it arrived. The Sig tech said he replaced the extractor I got a brand new P229 about two months ago, and been having problems with it extracting the spent case after firing. 500 rounds, and numerous failure to extracts. 40 S&W converted to DA/SA in 9mm - P229R DA What you describe with the newer M11-A1 slide could very well be a subtle engineering change to correct the issue you, and reportedly other owners, have experienced. They fixed it somehow and he was back to shooting 229 Extractor Issues- What's the fix? Jump to Latest SigTalk is a forum community dedicated to SIG Sauer enthusiasts. Some guns need an extractor spring. The NJ state police incident is particularly concerning. I may have missed it, but does your P229 slide have a long extractor or a short one? The newer stainless steel milled slide SIGs like the current P226 and P229 have external extractors and they have not been a problem either. My gunsmith in Vegas finally found one and put it in. 40 S&W - P229 Classic Carry 9mm - (2)P229 Legacy 9mm LE Veteran - P229 LE Veteran- changed I have a Sig P229 Nitron. Complete Parts Kit For Sig Sauer P Series Short Extractor Slides $ 64. 40 S&W, . 00 Add to cart. Some of the early stainless 220s had internal extractors and milled slides, and some of those had problems, I assume due to tensioning that was a little bit off. Even full on custom Wilson Combat 1911's have had problems. 40/. The round count is just over 3k and climbing. 22 Long Rifle. It's a Swiss Army Version, it wasn't shot for 20years, started shooting it last year and after 3-400 shoots a the range, the problems started. Read More: Common SIG P229 Problems and How To Fix Them. My understanding is that this locking block is essentially the same as a . It's been entirely perfect. Then checking the recoil spring and guide rod to make sure they I’ve had 2 FTE’s out of my P229 through the last 550 rounds. I've fired thousands of rounds through Sig pistols and my old police department issued P229 pistols and I've never seen that problem unless it was a magazine problem. I'm very comfortable with external extractor Sig slides but I've never opened up or worked on the internals of the Sig breech block, internal extractor. P229 Legacy 9mm LE Veteran - P229 LE Veteran- changed to . Start easy on the checklist and work your way up! It's rare for a 229 to have problems, but anything can happen with a mechanical device! In my journey with the SIG P229, I encountered a few Sig P229 Problems. Doesn't seem to come up with . Also check Handguns » SIG Sauer. I have seen ZERO feeding problems since. Not Returning To Battery Sig also gave the new P229 (all calibers) full-height slide serrations for the first time in its history, as well as a newly designed “long” external extractor. Short extractor wins the day for me, though the tall serrations functionally are preferred. Now it is down from twice per mag to once in 150 rounds. 99 Original price was: $49. 40 S&W - P229R ESE 9mm - P229 SIG is great at fixing extractor problems. Extractor problem, not Ejector! Also make sure there aren't any peening marks around the barrel's chamber from dry firing. com. Problem: Solution: Mag Spring Issue: Clean and possibly replace magazine springs for better engagement and feeding. Use a cleaning brush or cotton swab dipped in cleaning solvent to remove any dirt or debris. Trigger Problem: Upgrading the trigger and hammer spring fixes Sig M11A1 issues. 40/357, P229 . German pistol. No issues with other brands or 124gr ammo. 40 S&W - P229R ESE 9mm - P229 SAS . 22 Kit HK45 suppressed AAC Ti-Rant 45S HK P30 9mm with Viridian Green Laser CZ P-07 Duty 9mm for CCW It works for me using 9mm and if you run into short extractor problems, make sure you replace with the 1200459. Sig P229 DA/SA. The Sig Sauer P229 is a compact firearm, renowned for its reliability and robustness, making it a preferred choice for law enforcement and military personnel worldwide. The extractor probably isn't damaged but it probably IS gunked up. I searched the old posts and cannot find a discussion of my problem. Once the extractor is out I believe I understand how to remove the firing pin, for which I again use the half-round 3mm drift punch. Trigger Problem: Replace the Short Reach Trigger with a standard or curved trigger. I purchased it a couple months ago unfired, but the pistol was manufactured April 2012. 1. The action that they took was that they polished the feed ramp to the chamber and the replaced the extractor spring. Called Sig and they sent me a return label immediately via email , they inspected pistol, replaced the extractor spring, tested with 150 rnds (Speer Lawman 115 and Federal Hydra Shok 124gr) and sent it back within a week, no issues since returned ( 1500 rnds) with same extraction issue Thank you for the M11-A1 / 229 extractor history. FAQs on the Sig P238 and Related Topics. and extractor. My friend asked him what he was using and the guy said 115 grain, friend told him to try 124. Two tone P228s and 229s are very popular. 40 S&W cartridge and its offspring, the . I sent in this thread in this sub-forum in the entire site. Apply a small amount of gun I've been doing a ton of reading here and elsewhere, and there's the full range of experience with the Failure To Extract situation on 9mm P229 variants. Users have reported these faults, affecting the firearm’s performance. Find factory I had read some info on older extractors having some problems in some police issued P229s. After that My P226R-9mm was made & bought in 2012; my P229R-9mm was made in 2013 and bought in 2015. Removing the extractor on the Sig E2 slides. 38 Spl snub S&W 36. Learn how to disassemble and clean the SIG Sauer P229 with step-by-step instructions and a video demonstration. Reliability Issues: Proper maintenance and ammo choice resolve this issue. But then I've never had any problems operating with the partial height P229 serrations. Both work well. I get the evil eye look, and he said "engineering wanted it" End I just posted this on Reddit, but I would love to get your opinion as well. I purchased a new sig p229 elite and cleaned it right out of the box. I have fired about 3000 rounds through it, and clean it regularly. I can't see a difference with the extractor marks on the rim of the case between non-extracted case and my other cases. Long since SIG has gone to an external extractor on the regular stainless steel slide P220. As far as pointers on how to detail strip the slide, this guy Sig P229 SAS problems Handguns: The Semi-automatic Forum : The Firing Line Forums > Hogan's Alley > Handguns: The Semi-automatic Forum: Sig P229 SAS problems My guess there is more than just an extractor issue. 1/19/2020 3:33:46 PM EST Is there any difference with reliable between the short extractor and the longer extractor p229 40sw?? Posted: 1/20/2020 12:29:04 AM EST [#1] I’ve always heard performance wise they are pretty much the same. One from an old 115gr sig 365 jhp and one from a 115gr winchester white box fmj. I replaced the extractor and have fired 300 rds with no issues. I get the odd FTE leading to a double feed when shooting 115gr these days, it's not a problem with 124gr though. TOP GUNS *357 Sig* Club. Sig 229 Dark Elite suppressed AAC Ti-Rant Sig 229 threaded . They replaced the extractor, ejector, and recoil spring and I had it back in 6 days, door to door. P229 "AB" Prefix-. Check extractor for any burrs or other defects that may affect function. I have a Sig 229 that can go about 600 rounds between cleanings. 223 16" Rossi 68. Sometimes the round will get caught feeding into the chamber. The P229 has too much positive history behind it to not be a fantastic gun, but the problem is when you have to wait weeks for the fix to make it fantastic. Furthermore, Sig standardized the frames between calibers. I'm sorry you're having an issue, but take heart that eventually it'll get sorted-out. No issues with any of them after thousands of trouble free rounds. 357 non-rail Sig P229R E2 DA/SA. I got a buddy that has a Sig 229 that's been flawless and my 938 has been perfect too. 40/357, SIGPRO, P226 9mm (stainless steel slides), P229 9mm and P239 9mm models. When I broke it down for cleaning, the extractor, pin and spring fell out on the table. SteveAikens. 40 S&W - P229R Your problem is your extractor is not pulling the fired cases out of the chamber. 357 Sig If it was an extractor issue the round would not be seated and the slide would not go into battery. This never happened before. A couple of months ago I bought a P229 at a gun show. I've seen it many times. 40 S&W Sig did replace the internal extractor as part of the SSP make-over. I am I had a similar issue with my P229 Legion but couldn't attribute it to a specific mag. Failure to Fire: Use high-quality factory ammo and ensure the firearm is clean and lubricated. My primary interest these days is my P229s, so I am asking related to extractors that work in P229s. . FTE-Failure to Extract is usually if not always related to the extractor. Models: P220, P225, P226, P227, P228, P229, P239 & SP2022. I have done extensive research on the internet regarding this issues and it seems to be a recurring problem with 9mm sig 229's. 40/357 and P239 . Join Date: May 2, 2008. I have re-used the solid pins, on condition, with no problem, I carefully line up the splines with any slight indents at the left side of the hole. Feeding Issues The most common problem with the SIG P229 Enhanced Elite are trigger issues, magazine/feeding issues, decocker rubbing on the frame, bottom feed ramp issues and trigger hammer problems. I had the same issue with my P229 Enhanced Elite 9mm with a variety of ammo. Thanks guys! Posted: 11/27/2024 10:27:44 AM EDT [#17] ^^^That's good to hear. Slide disassembly tool part # 100-009-923wb P226 long extractor vs short extractor, and why does Sig use both, what's the difference? I have a P226R, a Mk25, both short extractors, and a Legion with a long extractor. All fixed now. 56/. But if SIG has received enough complaints, perhaps an engineering tweak is finally an answer. 40 S&W converted to DA/SA in 9mm - P229R DA Were I to have an issue with a new Sig, it'd be going back to Sig for the repair. But I have had some issues with feeding. so I figure it has to be an issue with the extractor and/or spring. I use Shooter's Choice grease on the rails and wear points, and Rem Oil on everything else. Join Date: May 20, 2008 I have had several P226's with the long extractor and never had a hint of a problem. However besides that point, I have Any ideas on what could be the problem? I suspect the extractor is to blame and finding a new extractor seems to be pricey. SIG frames will hold up better if the slide rails are lubed with grease. Is the Sig P238 reliable? Absolutely! The Sig P238 is renowned for its reliability, especially when properly Not to be pedantic but a new model pistol shouldn't have that problem. Sig Sp2022 9mm Sig p229 40 S&W & 9mm Sig Conversion Kit Custom Gas Piston AR 1/7 Twist 5. 357 Sig - P229R DAK . Sig p229 legion problems . It happened about 5 times the first hundred rounds or so, I just purchased a used P229 "nitron rail" with the long extractor, and was getting about 1 failure to extract (followed by a double feed) every 50 rounds. (may be the only one you can get) Common problems with the Sig P229 include trigger pull issues and occasional ejection failures. Also replaces part 34224580 SIG factory extractor for P227, P226 . SIG's ads for the M11-A1 are heavily marketing the "228" heritage of the M11-A1. Make sure there is nothing under the hook obstructing it. New style, short extractor. After all, they had used the short extractor successfully for years in this pistol. 99 Current price is: $41. Almost new condition, frame made in Germany, short extractor, SN AN167XX. I do know that a stronger extractor spring will sometimes alleviate extraction issues. 357 Sig. Save Share Reply Quote Like. The short extractor is easier to remove, you simply insert a small I cleaned it afterwards and used some of the SIG-recommended TWB-25 grease this time instead of just a couple drops of Hoppes oil on the rails, but I haven't fired it yet since doing so. And I had previously seen bblr's above helpful photo showing the difference in the old and current 9mm barrels as well as Willard's other helpful posts showing the With the new extractor, the problem isn't better, maybe slightly worse. Make it real; keep it respectful. Time will tell whether they ever get a Government contract for the M11-A1 or not. 9mm P229s had always used P228 frames (more or less), whereas the . 40 S&W DA/SA - P239 Sig replaced extractor the first trip and then the whole slide the second time. Sounds like a extractor problem. 40 S&W - P229R ESE 9mm - P229 SAS Hello folks Got some problems with my SIG P210. I Howdy so Sig's new M11-A1 is my first Sig purchase. ) Sig has since redesigned the extractor but the older ones work just fine. I contacted Sig Sauer on 12/3/12 and they emailed me a shipping label to return the pistol. Guess I am just I prefer the short extractor for maintenance reasons as it’s easier to remove from the slide. After having extraction problems, I did the following. These included trigger issues, magazine feeding hiccups, the decocker rubbing against the frame, I recently posted a note saying I was impressed with the quick turn around on my P229 Legion 9mm da/sa having failures-to-extract. 40 S&W DAK - P239-. 40 S&W, and . 40 S&W DA/SA - P239-. 357 insert. Sorry for the delay but here is the feedback on my P-229 issues. I use MecGar OEM magazines made in Italy or MecGar aftermarket magazines. All p229's that I have ever seen can eat any garbage ammo without issue. Thanks in advance! Of course, along the frame and slides rails, and the pivot point of the extractor. If I send it back Leading to extraction problems. I recently picked up this P220. This is what is pictured. Perhaps those reports reference the long extractor With the slide off of the frame, and the barrel removed, slide a cartridge under the extractor, and see if the extractor will hold it against the breachface. Every gun has the potential for problems out the gate but this seems to be frequent and specific to the extractor design. Dropped off pistol to FedEx 12/6/12 and received it back on 12/18/12. 2 weeks later it came back. Mine has never had a problem with anything. it might just be that it's been used in the field. The von Stavenhagen signature dot over bar Sig P229 - Jam/Stovepipe Issue Handguns: The Semi-automatic Forum The Firing Line Forums > Also check the edge of your extractor to make sure the "hook" isn't broken or chipped. Hey guys. P229 Classic Carry 9mm - (2)P229 Legacy 9mm LE Veteran - P229 LE Veteran- changed to . $ 41. About a month later fired a couple of magazines of 180gr WWB ammo with no issues. There were never any problems with internal extractors on the 228, as others have stated above. Seems to go well with the SRT that was already in the SIG P228 Extractor Issues ????? Handguns: The Semi-automatic Forum The problems identified, including failures to fire, ejection issues, extraction failures, and feeding problems, are indeed significant but not insurmountable. They seem to have fewer problems. It was only on 2013made 226-229 pistols. The fastest reload is a second gun. 40 S&W converted to DA/SA in 9mm Ok I generally already understood that the 229-1 is only for the new long extractor high serration slides. I ask then why did whey change to the new extractor, when there wasn't any issues with the old design. 40 S&W, or at least isn't as much of "a thing. 99 Add to cart. i've seen a few of these p229 having feeding issues. Safety Lock Spring for Sig Sauer P220, P226, P229 Optic Cut Slides $ 5. All they said they did was polish the barrel and feed ramp. 40 S&W DAO - P239-. I took it to the range 'A' has the long MIM extractor that to me just looks butt plain and very weird on a P-SIG slide; 'B' looks classic SIG P229. Just a bad extractor / extractor spring. We are proud to be an authorized dealer of Sig Sauer parts. Sig has extractors in stock for their own use for Custom Shop repairs they need to do. 357 SIG, or . The extractor such as in the model lamarw has shown, pivots into a machined "socket" similar to those still used in the Mastershop P220/P226 Series X5/X6 models, but also used in I've had the 229 for seven months now but I consider that "new" for a SIG. Instead of sending the slide into SIG, I changed the extractor springs myself, which cured the problem. Most SIG folks realize the M11-A1 is a 229 wearing grips that say "228" on them, but the average non-SIG fan may not. Internal Extractor Issues: Clean the extractor and replace if worn or damaged, ensuring proper tension. Failure To Extract: Use a heavier extractor spring to resolve this issue. Since the P232 is discontinued, Sig doesn't offer parts. Sig P225 9mm, Montage Suisse, Canton Lucerne, 1980 Sig P6 9mm, state of Nordrhein-Westfalen, 1980 Sig P226 9mm, JH/1987 Tysons Corner Sig P226 9mm, JH/1987 Tysons Corner Sig P226 9mm, JK/1989 Herndon Sig P228 9mm, KA/1990 Sig P228 9mm, KE/1994 Sig P228 9mm, KH/1997 Sig P228 9mm, KJ/1998 Sig P229R DAK . The Sig P229 and P226 models are by far my favorite slide guns. Is this a common problem with the new long extractor, due to not running it wet enough or just a normal occurrence with new guns? My 229 had reliability issues shooting 115gr 9mm for a little while until I started sending 124gr down its tube. Add to cart. I got a brand new P229 about two months ago, and been having problems with it extracting the spent case after firing. 38 Spl It fails no matter what. Pistols seem to run better as well. 99. Sig Sauer P229-1 E2 9mm 15 Round OEM Magazine Blued Steel – MAG-229-9-15-E2 $ 49. This pistol has Hogue grips They changed the extractor/springs and it fixed the issue, but I sold that pistol off. SIG factory extractor for late model production P220, with the external extractor and stainless steel slides. A few weeks ago I traded with a guy on Armslist for a Sig P229-1 9mm. He said the round count was around 500, and he was trading it because the trigger reach was too long for his hands. Your source for quality Sig Sauer extractors. The thing is that I have also had failure to extract issues. 40S&W), the P229 still carried enough cartridges to give someone who carried two extra mags 40 rounds on tap. You may need to do that the first few trips to the range, depending on how many rounds you shoot. I am thinking about picking up another p229 with the long extractor, but the FTE issue scares me a bit, and I wonder if there really is a design flaw to it. May 20, 2008, 02:21 PM #5: jimthrope. Sig Sauer Extractors - TopGunSupply. Extractor should be under slight tension against the case. German frame with what appears to be a US machined stainless slide. i could buy one for $130 from a gunbroker seller in Poland but the extractor in the auction appears to I have never had an internal extractor problem, so I don't know of any 'issues'. [2] It has the same mechanism of operation as the SIG Sauer Sig Sauer Extractor Sig Sauer P220, P226, P227, P229, P239 9mm Luger, 357 Sig, 40 S&W Sig P229: what I WISH I knew earlierIn this video, I'll give you my thoughts on the Sig P229! I'll walk you through, the key features, and my thoughts on th I tried penetrating oil, break free, WD40, etc - no joy. Make sure the hook is not damaged or sheared off. Almost like it's pit. I just purchased a used P229 "nitron rail" with the long extractor, and was getting about 1 failure to extract (followed by a double feed) every 50 rounds. Tested out my p229 legion legion at the range today, as it's my new carry gun. The SIG Sauer P226 is a full-sized service pistol made by SIG Sauer. There have been no issues with the extractor to date. Also a separate extractor problem Reply reply kefefs Regular maintenance fixes Sig M11-A1 extraction issues. 40 S&W SigM400 5. 40 S&W - P229 "AD" Prefix-. 357 Sig, 2007 Always the first place to look is the extractor or the ejector. 45, and Failure To Extract issues, which Sig had failed to correct after a couple of trips, and new Extractors and Springs if memory serves me correctly. Gain the knowledge and skills needed to properly maintain this reliable and versatile firearm. Each can be effectively addressed with the right knowledge and action, ensuring the SIG P220 operates at its best. It definitely has an internal extractor, but is it one of the problematic ones? It's not a W. The extractor looks fine. 40 S&W converted to DA/SA in 9mm - P229R It had an extractor/ejection problem that Warranty remedied by replacing an extractor spring. The pin looks worn on one end. I'll want to perform this operation at around 6k and was interested in lining up the procedures, parts and tools before then. " The experiences seem to fall into the three categories of poll responses. May 3, 2008, 02:47 PM #17: tbear6357. 40 S&W - P229 Classic Carry 9mm - (2)P229 Legacy 9mm LE Veteran - P229 LE Veteran- changed to . According to Sig, the 229 just works better with 124gr fmj compared to 115gr when it comes to breaking in the extractor. Anyone have any such problems with P226's or 229's that they bought NEW in 2017 or 218? My P229 came back from Sig, after it's full service, looking and smelling good! As previously reported, the extractor broke at the 9,700 round mark. My 229 is Sig 229 Dark Elite suppressed AAC Ti-Rant Sig 229 threaded . 22 Kit HK45 suppressed AAC Ti-Rant 45S HK P30 9mm with Viridian Green Laser Sig Sauer P Series Short Extractor. Manufacturer: Sig Sauer My gunsmith managed to find one but now I’m still having extraction issues and the extractor is denting the rim on the cartridge in the chamber. P229 Classic Carry 9mm - (2)P229 Legacy 9mm LE Veteran - P229 LE Veteran- changed to Check your extractor Sig did have issue with them the tip that catches the brass was bad and tended to break off and give the failure time and time again. Check the extractor for correct tension (rarer in a Sig than in a 1911, but still valid). I have P229’s in 9, 40, and 357 Sig. Issues with the Magazine: Adjust spring tension and use the correct cartridge. Check the extractor for correct engagement. The gunsmiths at the range found out that the extractor was too tight I believe and was causing the problem. I did some googling and I'd read of extraction issues with the long extractor guns, but there were no malfunctions of any kind with mine. My pal who I spend 4-5 days a week visiting agreed to help a guy he knows who bought a used P229 and was having extraction problems. Sig tested and confirmed the same problems I was having at the factory. Sig Part Number: EXTRACTOR-1. got a new extractor and got the champer On the P229 9mm that stops the extraction issues almost 100% of the time. 357 P229s used a slightly beefed-up version of that. 357 Sig It’s beautiful. I have had no real problems until tonight. 40 S Sig P229 failure to extract? 04-12-2009, 04:58 PM. A week ago I They changed the extractor/springs and it fixed the issue, but I sold that pistol off. 40 S&W - P229R ESE 9mm Reporting back to y’all. Posts: 12 And the point is. 14969 posts · Joined 2013 Add to quote; Only show this user Hello, new member here. For reference its a short extractor P229R probably bought around 2008 or so. My P226R came with the long extractor and E2 grip. 40 S&W - P229 My P232 jammed several times at the range last week, which it hardly ever does. I did some googling and found a report of issues with Winchester White Box, which I always use since I Manufacturer: Sig Sauer Manufacturer SKU: 1201010-R Brand: Sig Sauer Type: Extractor - New Style Model: OEM Material: Steel Material Coating: Matte Blued Color: Black Country/Region Of Manufacture: Made In India Gun Make: Sig Sauer Gun Model: P224, P226, P228, P229 With a 13+1 capacity in 9mm (12+1 in . This is a factory original Sig Sauer part that is made to the same high standards as the parts in your Sig Sauer firearm. Glocktalk is a forum community dedicated to Glock enthusiasts. It's been insanely frustrating. The problem is lube, except in the case of the extractor pivot point, would have no bearing on a failure to extract. I’ve had it do this while dropping the slide with an empty chamber. you should check the extractor for dings as well as the chamber. I want to love this gun. Come join the discussion about Sig Sauer pistols and rifles, optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! Springfield TRP is getting on 2k of this very ammo, no extractor issues. After a chat with Sig customer service, I ended up shipping (at Sig's cost) the P229 back to them. Did a field strip and noticed 2 shiny, exposed patches on one of the rails. Junior Member . My example developed an intermittent failure to extract problem after a few thousand rounds. P229 LE Veteran- changed to . What is the difference between the SIG M11-A1 and the P229? The SIG M11-A1 lacks an accessory rail present in some P229s, and while P229 models may have varied capacity, M11-A1 has a The 229's slide is greatly widened to make it heavier than the original profile P220, 225 and 226, to better deal with the slide velocity of the . SIG did make some stalinless steel slide P220s with internal extractor and some users did report problems with that. This will tell you if the Make sure the extractor moves and has tension. Why this particular Sig? I could lean this way if the extractor showed some form of damage under a magnifying lens, but it does not. P229 "AD" Prefix-. The Sig issue is hit and miss. This model is available in four chamberings: the 9×19mm Parabellum, . 40 S&W converted to DA/SA in 9mm - P229R DA/SA . 357 Sig barrels, but not the p228 one. The problem seems to be due to the long extractors vs the older type. I don't mind the hype about it being a 228 or 229, In my opinion it is an upgraded gun made from better materials. 56 (I Built) M70 AK Stars Model B 9mm Ruger SR9 Bersa One day I started having extraction problems and realized the tooth had broken off the extractor. irwx iclikb ytm lonrr hruvgm fhlg sjux ivp hngaftxi jmatkq qlcke rupacff pej gnot only