Ncoer senior rater comments. Senior Rater Comments.

Ncoer senior rater comments The second concern (about the senior rater giving a '2' while the rater rates 'fully capable') is not as big of an issue. In reality the senior rater's markings are more consistent with the other markings on the rater's evaluation (that of 2 excellence and 3 success checks). MOS 92G Duty Descriptions. 3. She has the leadership qualities, technical skills, and discipline to fill any position that the Army has to offer. Evaluation Entry System (EES) Walk-through; 7. 2017 Category: Comments Author: ncoer. See examples of praise, promotion, and assignment recommendations for outstanding NCOs. If it makes you feel better my first E5 NCOER had me enumerated as 5 out of 5 in my section. PK !×ýJ. Critical Point: Separating Rater and Senior Rater & keeping supervisors at lowest levels have been keys to success for over 32 years (since introduction of DAForm 67-8 and 2166-9) NCOER Bullets. 1. There is a specific format for those comments. He is a phenomenal NCO whose excellent performance and vast potential are true testaments of his character and values. Consummate professional; promote ahead of peers; consistently performs two pay grades above contemporaries; Senior Rater NCOER Narrative Comment Examples. Regarding SR comments, see what u/monos2019 mentioned, but note that without a “range” enumeration means nothing. Examples can be contributed by using the form below. Senior Rater comments for Counseling Form. Why is NCOER locked? The Rater or Senior Rater is currently editing the That is a senior rater comment. This change in senior rater accountability will eliminate inflation, the rater will use his/her experience when providing comments. The comments state I am in the top 10% of all NCOs ever served with in 11 years and to “Send to ALC immediately and promote ahead of peers. Their signature validates their judgment and overall comments. See how to praise, recommend, and promote your soldiers with o clearly a superior Senior NCO with unlimited potential; will serve the Army well at the most senior levels of enlisted leadership o to maximize his potential, assign to positions of increased Learn how to write effective rater comments for the Noncommissioned Officer Evaluation Report (NCOER) based on the Army's performance measures and standards. has placed you where 80% of the formation is: good potential, but not number one yet and needs a little more shaping. Understanding the new NCOER: By now everybody involved should have received several LPDs, or briefings, on the new NCOER. But ultimately the SR Comments is what truly matters. Depending on your unit and chain of command, a varying amount of emphasis is put on making NCOER bullet comments "match" the rating. NCOER part IV: block c-APFT Action required: In the space after the word "APFT" the rater will enter "PASS" or "FAIL" and the date (YYYYMMDD) of the most recent record APFT administered by the unit; it will be within the 12-month period prior to the "THRU" date of report. MENU. What do you put if you don't really know the reason? For example, what if the soldier simply failed to balance his calorie intake with regular exercise. United States Army Senior Rater) •Counseling documented on support and counseling forms. o ordered over $1,200,000. Key Changes; 1. Army Regulation AR 623-3, EVALUATION REPORTING SYSTEM, prescribes the policies for completing evaluation reports that assess the performance and potential of officers, warrant officers, and enlisted personnel in the United States Army. MOS 18Z/Special Forces Senior Sergeant; To contribute examples, use this form. Senior OCT Signal Team Chief Special Missions Unit Squad Leader Squad leader Sr Systems Technician TAC NCO Team Leader Technical Just got on AGR and received this senior rater comment from my last job: "SGT Soandso shows the potential to succeed in any position or job he is assigned. PNG; 7. promote to SFC immediately Senior Rater Comments Excels in developing robust internal controls and monitoring mechanisms that are critical to achieving mission objectives in support of the Guam National Guard. 2017 Category: Comments Author: ncoer 0. r/army. With continued Senior rater bullet comments are mandatory and should focus on potential for promotion, higher level schooling and positions of greater responsibility, but may also address performance, and/or the evaluation rendered by the rater. for. 10. Values Comments; Training; Senior Rater Comments; Review by the NCO Journal Four and half Stars; Responsibility & Accountability; Red Skelton’s Commentary On The Pledge; Download Fillable DA Form 4187; Download DD214 Form Online; Using proper counseling in conjunction with the -1A ensures the Soldier is well informed and knows exactly where they stand with their Rater and Senior Rater at all times. Optimize your NCO evaluations with Army NCOER Writer, What are the requirements for the senior rater's comments in Part V? Get Embed Code. Senior Rater NCOER Narrative Comment Examples. performance only and the senior rater will assess potential. " 2 or 3 out in the top 5% Rater assesses Performance I Senior Rater assesses Potential 5 "Tried and True" SR Narrative Components: Service Potential, Next Higher Grade Highlights most The NCOER bullet comments below are examples of Excellence, Success, Senior rater bullets need to be clear, concise and reflect potential for promotion and higher levels of authority and responsibility. Excels, Proficient, Capable, or Unsatisfactory If I Disagree With My NCOER, What Can I Do? Any mention of unproven derogatory information in an evaluation report can become an appealable matter if the derogatory information is shown to be unfounded. MOS 92F Award Examples. This regulation includes instructions for carrying out the Army's officer, non-commissioned officer, and academic evaluation reporting MOS 92F, Petroleum Supply/Fuels Specialist NCOER Bullet Examples. With continued mentorship from senior NCOs, they have the potential to be a productive Senior NCO. Complete filling out any Admin data that was not carried over from the Support Form. Find tips and examples for writing OER narratives and NCOER bullets based on AR and DA PAM 623-3. Successive, Broadening Assignments. knox. ~ Mentor Military MOS 92G, Culinary Specialist NCOER Bullet Examples. Users share tips and examples on how to write effective rater/sr comments for NCOERs, especially when the rated soldier is top block material but the profile does not allow it. MOS 88M Duty Descriptions. When are NCOERs due? To HRC No later than 90 days from the thru date. So the DS that got a "did not meet standards" NCOER (i was the rater) got SR Comments that reflected their incompetency. MOS 13F Duty Descriptions. The role of supplementary reviewer has been added and there are certain cases when a supplementary review is required. ArmyNCO. Other than a relabeling of the Senior Rater box checks, the Senior Rater portion continues to operate using the Senior Rater Managed Profile Technique for these grades. Total Army asset select for First Sergeant now. The Senior Rater profile system for LTCs and below remains a four-box system. 18. The subject line should contain "SR Request for Signature NCOER Part IVc. − Stand-alone evaluation for a specific rating period − Rater comments focused on specific, higher. SSG Figueroa is two of six Staff Sergeants who I currently senior rate. g. hrc. SGT Colby Costa is the #1 NCO that I rate in this grade and is one of the finest transportation experts in the NCO Corps. 4. MOS 13F Senior Rater. Logically, no APFT information is authorized on evaluations since that is no longer a fitness test of record. The senior rater’s assessment of the rated NCO’s overall potential will be unconstrained which I had not run into this until now, but am currently doing the senior rater comments for a Soldier that retires next month. Army evaluations. MOS 92Y Duty Descriptions. Critical for “no box check” OERs. Contact As senior enlisted leader of 2D Stryker Brigade, Command Sergeant Major Hill demonstrated exceptional leadership, outstanding resourcefulness and superior performance while facilitating the highest mission readiness in all facets of operations. However, the APFT date does not have to fall senior rater bullet comments SGT Kite is a tireless NCO whose concern for his fellow Soldiers and commitment to his profession are evident in all he does. APFT. More posts you may like r/army. xml ¢ ( Ä–Ûnƒ0 †ï'í Pn'HÛ 4M¥½Øár«´í Rb $QâžÞ~¦P4MméÖ"n ‚íÿûí äáx•gÞ ¬Kµ Y?è1 T¤eªf!ûüxñï Published by: 18. Thanks for your contributions! We need more examples. Senior rater bullet comments must be clear, concise and should reflect the senior rater’s recommendation to Hundreds of Senior Rater NCOER bullets to aid in the preparation of Part V Overall Performance and Potential of the DA Form 2166-8 NCO Evaluation Report (NCOER). Aviation Tech Supply Clerk. uniformed Army-designated rating officials, senior rater or someone outside the rating chain directs relief) NCOER Support Form aligned with Army Doctrine (ADP 6-22) −New senior rater comments box −Senior rater should counsel at least twice during rating period Discourage creation of large senior rater populations (pooling) NCOER Rater/SR Comments . Find examples of senior rater comments for NCOERs, the Noncommissioned Officer Evaluation Report. com. 04. EES Main Screen. MOS 13F Award Examples. See also: Air Force Individual Protective Equipment (IPE) Examples. These bullets may continue to prove benefitial as an aid in developing a Senior Rater Narrative; however, they will soon be replaced with with actual Narrative Statements in order to fully support the recent Meet NCOER / OER Assistant GPT: an AI tool for efficient Non-Commissioned Officer Evaluation Reports and Officer Evaluation Reports. " 2 or 3 out in the top 5% Rater assesses Performance I Senior Learn how to write effective comments for the Senior Rater Potential Evaluation (SRPE), a document that assesses an employee's leadership potential for promotion and key positions. Responses: 7 Sort By. Number 1 of 6 SFCs I senior rate OR among the top 15% of xxseries SFCs I have served with in my 13 year career. SSG Smith is an outstanding team leader with demonstrated potential for positions of increased responsibility. MOS 35F Duty Descriptions. The senior rater comments are for the board, not the rated officer. Rater – The immediate supervisor who assesses performance. directions for how to enter explanatory statements in the comments block. o oversaw the integration and in-processing of approximately 4,000 Soldiers to Fort Sill annually o guided operations during the sequestration budget reduction in FY14; maintained graduation numbers o ensured training resources were flexible and scalable to handle training needs for years to come If the Rated Soldier applied a signature and no longer has a CAC, the SENIOR RATER can request that the signature be removed by HQDA by sending an email to the Evaluations Policy mailbox (usarmy. 0 0 0 0. The Senior Rater profile for these grades continues with the limitation of less than 50%. o operated and maintained the S2 Section for the Battalion Rear Detachment performing the duties and tasks of a senior non-commissioned officer Bullet Comments. 14 14 0 SSG Robert Senior Rater bullet comments that stick out to board members are those that are tangible, not When a supplementary review is not required, the senior rater will ensure the NCOER meets the regulatory guidance of AR 623-3. Click “NEXT” Complete filling out the to bullet comments on NCOER. comrrün SR The senior rater profile for the New NCOER will be limited to 24% top block or “MOST QUALIFIED” selection. The following forms are used for the NCO Evaluation Report (NCOER). NCOER Bullet Examples for Presence, Character, Intellect, Leads, Achieves, and Develops. MOS 88M, Motor Transport Operator NCOER bullet examples. Find hundreds of bullets for senior rater NCOERs from various MOSs and ranks. Senior Drill Sergeant. o organized and prepared the unit for redeployment and reintegration into central region upon completion of their 15 month deployment with zero loss of accountability the US Army Evaluations Guide as you develop your comments for the NCOER. Duty Title. Before picking up the pencil to make comments on your -1A you need to totally understand the processthen you can start putting comments on your -1A. ž ( [Content_Types]. A practice that I did was I would give my PL or XO my "proposed SR Comments" on the rated NCO, and then they would adjust it based upon how they see fit. Comments in the senior rater box include comments: -When the senior rater has not been in the position the minimum number of days necessary to evaluate the rated NCO, he or she will enter the following statement in part Senior Rater NCOER Narrative Comment Examples. Forms. o promote to Master Sergeant ahead of peers; Bullet Comments. Can one simply say: o Soldier failed to meet height and weight Senior rater bullet comments are mandatory and should focus on potential for promotion, higher level schooling and positions of greater responsibility, but may also address performance, and/or the evaluation rendered by the rater. Provide the field with the best Air Traffic Controllers in the world. • Nowthat we’ve transitioned to the ACFT, the comments must address the record ACFT status for the rated Soldier. 00 worth of supplies and equipment to ensure Team Renegade maintenance readiness and missions success Bullet Comments. com's sample Senior Rater NCOER Bullets - Your only source for sample Senior Rater NCOER Bullets to help you prepare the DA FORM 2166-8 (NCOER). Sample Army OER Senior Rater Comments. Back to CMF 35 NCOER Bullets. I believe that most of the people who haven’t bought into this CMF 18, Special Forces NCOER Bullet Examples. See also: Values NCOER Bullets. A brief discussion on the importance of the NCOER support form and how to interpret the Senior Rater comment section. MOS 35F (previously 96B), Intelligence Analyst NCOER bullets. The Senior Rater’s evaluation is more strategic, considering the NCO’s capability to perform in higher positions. Creating an NCOER Support Form. DA PAM 623-3 Para 3-7. addressed in the Senior Rater’s comments. Bullets will not be longer than two lines, MOS 13F, Fire Support Specialist, NCOER Bullets. This document is divided into two main areas: SGT NCOER Direct Level bullet comments and SSG-MSG NCOER Organizational level bullet comments. MOS 42A, Human Resources Specialist, NCOER bullets. NCOER Bullets Sorted by Category. Recommended Positions. The BDE CSM was the rater, and the BDE CDR was the SR. Ensure 100% support for all flight training missions. Introduction to the New NCOER; 1. Senior rater may recommend/request discharge, separation or QMP uniformed Army -designated rating officials, senior rater or someone outside the rating chain directs relief) NCOER Support Form aligned with Army Doctrine (ADP 6- 22) −New senior rater comments box −Senior rater should counsel at least twice during rating period Discourage creation of large senior rater populations (pooling) Approved Changes The NCOER is an assessment tool. Sergeant First Class Chavez is an exceptional Soldier who exemplifies trust up and down the chain of command. My senior rater then doubled down and enumerated me 15 out of 15 in the platoon SR "3 out of SR and In of SR has (fewer tt*n 5 25 at of In top of SR of 50 sa SDE of t staff o pulation rage in top (¥8 of 40 • to Top 1-5% e SR "Top 1% officer') dutiE • on _ 10-15% of 42 st with. They provide a supplemental assessment, focusing on the Rated NCO’s potential for future challenges and responsibilities. Back to CMF 13 NCOER Bullets. Back to CMF 88 NCOER Bullets. of 48) Number (2 or 3) of (total like or total population) e. S. I am used to recommending schools, commenting on promotability, and suggesting successive assignments in NCOER's, but what does one do when you know there are no further assignments, no further schools, HQ DA takes this delineation very seriously. • The best rater and senior rater narratives: Are short; tell a simple story about the quality of officer being evaluated; focus on potential 3-5 years out (promotions, command, school, & assignments. DA Form 2166-9-1A (Support Form) DA Form 2166-9-1 (E-5, Direct-level) Senior Rater NCOER Narrative Comment Examples. Sergeant Young has demonstrated keen managerial and developmental skills during her short time in her current position establishing effective and long Senior Rater Comments SPC Trowbridge demonstrated exceptional adaptability by taking on responsibilities well beyond his pay grade. Reply reply Top 1% Rank by size . If they write department OIC instead of command, only the AMEDD half of the board know that’s a good thing. Most people understand where the Army is going with this new, improved evaluation system, but there are some people out there who are resistant to change and simply don’t like it. Back to CMF 92 NCOER Bullets. He continually strives to improve his technical and tactical Senior Rater comments on overall performance during the reporting period. Bullet comments will— 1. tagd-eval-policy@army. Be short, concise, to the point. The supplementary reviewer, when required, To ensure the rated NCO receives an accurate and fair assessment, the rater’s comments will focus on specific, quantifiable performance. Related Tools. Changes to the Evaluation Reporting System; 1. Sergeant Young has demonstrated keen managerial and developmental skills during her short time in her current position establishing effective and long-lasting structures that will impact the entire Army Reserve IMA Management Program. His/her purpose is only to opine on your future for increased responsibility and satisfactory performance in same. Senior Rater Comments. He flawlessly managed and maintained 100% accountability of unit equipment valued at over $100,000, a task typically reserved for higher-ranking personnel. Click “NEXT” 12. Home; NCOERS; Awards; Counseling; Contact; Senior Rater NCOER Bullets (DA FORM 2166-8 Legacy Bullets) Headlines. Contact Who Signs the NCOER? Four key individuals sign the NCOER: Rated NCO – The soldier being evaluated. The assessment format has also changed as the senior rater comments will be written in narrative Just looking for some insight in regards to my SR comments on my current NCOER draft. Administrative NCOIC. Back to NCOER Bullets by MOS. New Rater Tendency Profile; 1. Totally dedicated to unit, mission and soldiers; Senior Rater Comments. My number one of two E-5s, he has repeatedly demonstrated that he is supremely qualified to take on greater responsibility as a SSG. Senior rater bullet comments must be clear, concise and should reflect the senior rater’s recommendation to . As a senior rater, you have a vital role in the promotion eligibility and career opportunities for the people you evaluate. A senior rater deliberating on the potential progression of junior NCOs can utilize the tool to effectively weigh and articulate future roles for which an NCO might Provides an overview of the regulation, citing paragraphs and page numbers in the regulation, over 1,000 NCOER bullet comments for all portions of the NCOER broken down by These are further divided into 15 subcategories to assist the rater and senior rater, gives guidance on relief for cause reports, how to appeal, providing Examples of Character NCOER Bullets. o oversaw the maintenance and repair of 10 wheeled vehicles during annual training at CSMS resulting in increased operational readiness of the Battalion o worked on the FARP during the Situational Training Exercise and issued over 39,000 lbs of fuel to four aircraft (MH-47 Chinook, MH-60 Blackhawk, MH-64 Apache, and MC-12) 18. An NCO I know has an eval from her time as the BDE Commander's Executive Assistant. Posted 11 y ago Follow this discussion Respond. ” But then I was checked for highly qualified. Learn how to use effective words, avoid prohibited and negative comments, and strengthen or weaken box checks. r. It's a decent evaluation until you The third step involves the Senior Rater. SGT X is in the top XX% of 35Fs I have worked with throughout my 20 year career. That s. When promotion boards review the person’s evaluation reports, they Back to NCOER. o Senior logistics advisor for 581 personnel in an Aviation Maintenance organization; Comments/Contributions: o fearless senior NCO; identified and stopped behavior risking group conflict or harassment claims; held work center to standards o followed up on training mileposts, improved key coverage by 80% in less than 3 months o fostered open, candid, and frequent communications between command and all Bn members In all honesty the worst NCOER Comments I've ever seen was the lack of comments. mil) explaining in detail why the request is being made. Example of appropriate comments for Part IV, block i include "o serving as rater and senior rater in accordance with AR 623–3, paragraphs 2–19" (or para 2–20 as applicable) or "o serving as rater and senior rater in accordance with the CG, HRC exception to NEGATIVE COMMENTS: (see sections) References CAN be made to the following (if verified) in Part IV, V or any NCOER Enclosure; DO NOT put a negative comment unless it has been verified and there is counseling to back it up (except in the rarest circumstances). It offers custom prompts, format assistance, and performance insights for accurate U. I’m being rated as a SL as an e5(not promotable). Each main area is subdivided by CMF to better assist you in finding the information that best pertains to you and your Soldiers. ) Quantify officer’s value relative to peers and do so in concert with senior rater box check. mbx. SR mature (Not As Strong) P Otential Schooling d Pote Not to Write Notes and rated of 25 with of SAMS SSC. Her ability to plan, organize, and execute technical analyses is evident in her effective management of budget functions, which are essential to the readiness missions of the Guam National Guard. I recently watched an HRC video addressing the top five reasons that NCOERs are being returned for correction, and potential remarks in the rater’s comments was number two on that list! Next, in my opinion, the Rater Overall Performance bullets should be brief and to-the-point. Senior Rater – A higher-ranking leader who Hundreds of Senior Rater NCOER bullets to aid in the preparation of Part V Overall Performance and Potential of the DA Form 2166-8 NCO Evaluation Report (NCOER). 2. mp4; Senior Rater Four-Box-Check System Policy Change: Incorporates the senior rater four-box-check system and senior rater profile label for DA Form 2166-9-2 (SSG –1SG/MSG) and DA Form 2166-9-3 (CSM/SGM). MOS 92Y, Unit Supply Specialist NCOER Bullet Examples. The senior rater will also assume the role/responsibility of reviewer. o received exemplary comments during CG's Thanksgiving Best Mess competition; 92g40 Senior Food Operations Sergeant. Back to NCOER Bullets. Contact According to DA PAM 623-3, when noncompliance with height/weight standards is not met, the rater should indicate the reason for noncompliance. CBRN Specialist. ”); these are considered prohibited narrative comments Senior Rater Narrative. Policy Clarification: In part V, block a, the senior rater will assess the rated NCO’s potential compared to all NCOs of the same rank: Back to NCOER Bullets. o inspected equipment and ensured it was to standard for turn-in and turned it in in a timely manner; supported the unit in the rapid removal of excess inventory Bullet Comments. STRONG SENIOR RATER PERFORMANCE AND POTENTIAL BULLETS. •Final assessment documented on evaluation form. These bullets may continue to prove benefitial as an aid in developing a Senior Rater Narrative; however, they will soon be replaced with with actual Narrative Statements in order to fully support the recent comments) Notes Stron 'Exclusive #1 or my Best of SIR Prone (i. e. MOS 35F Award Examples. Senior Rater Comments Excels in developing robust internal controls and monitoring mechanisms that are critical to achieving mission objectives in support of the Guam National Guard. See comments) Notes Stron 'Exclusive #1 or my Best of SIR Prone (i. 0 shares. Total Army asset select for First Sergeant now Consummate professional; promote ahead of peers; Posted in these groups: NCOER Promotion Board. corrected Soldiers when questionable comments were made that might offend other Soldiers EO and EEO principles through word and deed; served as an example for seniors, peers and subordinates to emulate Senior Mechanic NCOER Bullets o assumed Motor Sergeant duties in his absence and successfully provided maintenance support for over 25 trucks and 5 trailers during Annual Training o aggressively managed shop activities completing 32 scheduled services with limited manning, funds or equipment during the holiday seasons and high op-tempo taskings Senior Mechanic. 16 Senior raters need to amplify their potential box checks by Based on HRC's Board/NCOER Guidance (from 2008-2009), Promote Now/Immediately are interchangeablepromote ahead of peers corresponds with 2/2 senior rater rating. New Senior Rater Profile; Senior Rater Comments; 6. MOS 74D CBRN NCOER Bullets. Attached is an OER Narrative Guide and NCOER Bullet Guide the Rater and Senior Rater, to break your writer’s block and create unique narratives and bullets for your officers and NCOs, in Each attribute/competency is broke down by level of rater box check that comment supports (e. Since the ratings are Needs Improvement, Success, or Excellence, bullet comments are expected to be written so that they coincide with these ratings. Find out how to HQ DA takes this delineation very seriously. The criteria for these ratings is shown in the table below: o volunteered to see 10 referrals per week from the Audiology Clinic at CRDAMC while their capacity was suddenly reduced to 50% o provided medical expertise and leadership, ensuring the safety and effectiveness of over 300 personnel during multiple field training exercises, including a week-long multi-nation event, Spring Storm 2024, resulting in zero injuries ArmyNCO. Published by: 18. Bullet Comments. TC ccR: Potential. He managed 37 unit personnel and mentored and encouraged new and junior Soldiers to excel individually. o advise 11 Officers and one senior NCO on 10 major logistic and personnel platforms, including PBUSE, Bullet Comments. Successive and Broadening Assignments; 7. MOS 92F Duty Descriptions. xat teeslg lzus qwzxcj zdplvrf xfb gwxqqwc veo ycoy kopv zljoy svzw rkox hwteln oufgt